2026 NFL Draft RB Debate: Is This Class Worth the Pick?

This 2026 NFL Draft running back class gives you burst, receiving value, and a few backs with real starter upside, but the sacrifice is using a meaningful pick on a group that also feels thin, injury-heavy, and full of role-player projections. If a team chases the wrong traits here, are they buying speed and flash while passing on better value somewhere else?

Follow us on Spotify so you do not miss the next live-to-audio upload, and if you enjoy the show, give us a 5-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts.

In this episode, Drew and Rob kick off their 2026 draft coverage by breaking down the running back class from the bottom up and asking the question that hangs over the whole show: is this actually a class worth investing in, or is it a bad year to force a pick at the position? The discussion keeps coming back to the same tradeoff. There is clear upside in this group, but there are also durability concerns, ball-security problems, pass-protection flaws, age concerns, and more than a few backs who feel like complementary pieces instead of true long-term answers.

The show spends time sorting through the role-player and value tier first, including Seth McGowan, Kaelon Black, J’Mari Taylor, Kaytron Allen, Jaydn Ott, and Le’Veon Moss. Some bring size, some bring steady downhill value, and some have enough traits to stick in an NFL backfield, but most of them come with obvious limitations. Whether it is injury history, a capped ceiling, pass-protection concerns, or overlap with what the Giants already have, Drew and Rob make it clear that a lot of these backs feel more like depth options than players you should be excited to spend real capital on.

Then the conversation shifts into the more compelling names in the class. Nicholas Singleton gets real respect for his size, speed, receiving value, and pass protection, but there are still vision and medical questions that keep him from being an automatic RB1. Mike Washington Jr. has the size-speed profile teams love, but the ball-security issue is loud enough to make the projection risky fast. Jonah Coleman gets praised as one of the safer all-around evaluations, even if the big-play ceiling is limited.

The biggest praise in the episode goes to Emmett Johnson, Jadarian Price, and Jeremiyah Love. Emmett Johnson is framed as one of the most underrated backs in the class because of his workload, receiving production, consistency, and overall football value. Jadarian Price gets strong support for his burst, return value, and ability to maximize touches even while sharing a backfield. Jeremiyah Love lands at the top because of the explosive profile, home-run ability, and feature-back upside, even though Drew still pushes back on the idea that he should be treated like some untouchable generational prospect.

By the end, the show is not just ranking backs. It is drawing a line between exciting traits and smart draft value. That is the real debate running through the whole episode: when this class has so many questions attached to it, how early is too early to take a running back, and which of these backs is actually worth betting on?

Merch: https://2giantgoofballs-shop.fourthwall.com/

Support: https://buymeacoffee.com/2giantgoofballs

All episodes: https://2giantgoofballs.buzzsprout.com/